KU2
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com

So many levels of crazy

who's talking here?

TexasOma 1
justforfun1 1
AuthorMan 1
Sincerely 1
Bornanraisedkw 1
Pepper 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Sincerely --- 13 years ago -

Civil Right to Government-Provided Sex Change?

Convicted soldier Bradley Manning has announced his real self is as a woman named Chelsea. Ok.

More: His lawyer says this isn’t a private issue, but a public one. He has insisted that the U.S. government provide for Manning’s ”transition” as he does his prison time in Leavenworth. Well, that opened my eyes without having to drink my morning coffee.

More: His lawyer apparently plans to sue to make sure we pay for it. From the CNN story:Manning’s lawyer, David Coombs, told “Today” that he hopes officials at Fort Leavenworth military prison will provide his client the hormone therapy. “I’m hoping Fort Leavenworth would do the right thing and provide that,” Coombs said. “If Fort Leavenworth does not, then I am going to do everything in my power to make sure that they are forced to do so.

Coombs threat to sue is essentially a claim that there is a civil right to become the sex one believes oneself to be, and moreover, that the government must provide that treatment to a prisoner under its authority–just as it would have to pay for cancer treatment or any other necessary “medical” service or procedure.  

I would be shocked if the courts so ruled, but I have been shocked a lot the last few decades.We are heading in that general direction.

The Obamacare birth control mandate was at least partly put into place–according to DOJ legal briefs–to ensure legal equality for women. LGBT advocates could logically make the same claim for required coverage for sex change procedures. San Francisco’s public health insurance already does.

Transsexual rights, if that is the proper term, is moving forward. California just enacted a law requiring public schools to allow children to use bathrooms and locker rooms of the opposite sex when they identify with that sex. In other words, one no longer requires a legal ruling reassigning sex.

The DOJ took the same position in a lawsuit that was filed by parents upset that a school did not allow their son to use the girl’s bathroom. The case settled in favor of the parents.

Moreover, not fully on point but pertinent to the discussion: A bill has passed the California Legislature requiring group health plans pay for infertility treatments for gays and lesbians in the same way it does heterosexuals. 

As I wrote in the Weekly Standard, under the terms of California law, such a law would mean that once a gay couple did not conceive after one year of trying, they would be entitled to have the costs of treatment paid, e.g.. artificial insemination, surrogacy potentially, etc.

Once again, this would not be unprecedented. In the UK, lesbians are entitled to free provision of a sophisticated form of artificial insemination under the NHS.

If we keep requiring insurance coverage for “consumerist” as well as “medical” procedures, there is no way we will ever control health care costs. 

TexasOma (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

I keep saying "the world has turned upside down'.

Maybe I should retire to Russia, specifically Siberia, somewhere out in the middle of absolutely no where.

How can they even justify this? This MAN has been sentenced to prison, a male prison. So, he gets this sex change operation (at least the hormone therapy part of it) and he's still a MAN by law. Doesn't that make him the bell of the ball being the only female resident of a male prison? Or, are they going to move this MAN into a FEMALE prison? It's just absolutely stupid.

And, if he wants to have reassignment therapy, why doesn't his family cough up the money, why should we, the taxpayers, do so.

And for transsexual rights....................If I want a boob job (God forbid) I would be forced to pay for it myself - right? Well, they want a reassignment, so they should pay for it themselves. This is stupid. Well, maybe I could claim that I feel inadequate and only a boob job would make me feel better about myself so the insurance company should have to pay for it, I'll wait until Obamacare kicks in and make that claim --- I'll add "and I love Obama, I voted for him!!" (that hurt just to type it).

Our world had turned upside down. 

justforfun1 (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

This jerk wants to demand the people pay for his sex change? We have people that need kidney, heart and liver transplants that can't afford them but this jerk wants to be put first. Leave him like he is and if the men there want to have some fun, allow them. 

Pepper --- 13 years ago -

Other than keeping him locked up for the next 35 years, I don't want one dime of my tax dollars going to benefit this guy.

He'll just have to live with his identity issues ... 

AuthorMan (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

The kid has nothing to worry about- they will treat him like a girl in Leavenworth. 

Bornanraisedkw --- 13 years ago -

Haha I thought u were referring to KU at first... Lol 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

KU2